Pie Shops in New York page 2

We found 73 pie shops across New York, with the biggest clusters in Levittown, Rensselaer, West Babylon, and Bayside. Hover a name to spot it on the map; tap Route for directions.

Pie Shops by city

New York 11Brooklyn 9Warwick 3East Aurora 3

Closest to you

Share your location once and we will sort bakeries from closest to farthest, with the distance to each.

Showing 41–73 of 73. Hover a bakery to find it on the map.

  1. 41. Mr. Pot Pie

    718 Main St, East Aurora, NY 14052

    Pie shop (716) 805-7924 Route

  2. 42. PersNikkity Pies

    9 E Main St, Falconer, NY 14733

    Pie shop (716) 294-3368 Route

  3. 43. Sweetie Pies Bakery & Cafe

    512 E Colvin St, Syracuse, NY 13210

    Pie shop (315) 345-2971 Route

  4. 44. Mr. Pot Pie

    718 Main St, East Aurora, NY 14052

    Pie shop (716) 805-7924 Route

  5. 45. Cindy's Pies

    5 Academy St, Naples, NY 14512

    Pie shop (585) 374-6122 Route

  6. 46. Everything Pie Bakery

    East Aurora Cooperative Market, 100 Riley St, East Aurora, NY 14052

    Pie shop (716) 949-0668 Route

  7. 47. Pieconic

    20 Main St, Chatham, NY 12037

    Pie shop (518) 392-2988 Route

  8. 48. Nelly's Pop-Up Pies & Bakery

    267 Park Ave, Binghamton, NY 13903

    Pie shop (607) 237-8531 Route

  9. 49. Shannon's Eyes on the Pies

    252 Pine Island Turnpike, Warwick, NY 10990

    Pie shop (845) 324-8915 Route

  10. 50. Uncle Jeff's Pecan Pies and More

    3263 Mark Alan Dr, Wantagh, NY 11793

    Pie shop (516) 804-2190 Route

  11. 51. Daly Pie

    665 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

    Pie shop (347) 425-9251 Route

  12. 52. F&s Pies

    1017 154th St, Whitestone, NY 11357

    Pie shop (718) 321-2915 Route

  13. 53. Fancy Pies - Pies For Every Season

    839 W 181st St, New York, NY 10033

    Pie shop (646) 504-7437 Route

  14. 54. Foibles

    172 Rhode Island St, Buffalo, NY 14213

    Pie shop (716) 931-5808 Route

  15. 55. Mr Pot Pie

    141 Buffalo St, Hamburg, NY 14075

    Pie shop (716) 202-1717 Route

  16. 56. Oggies

    445 Albee Sq, Brooklyn, NY 11201

    Pie shop (631) 825-9176 Route

  17. 57. Panini Pie Factory

    71 Milbar Blvd, Farmingdale, NY 11735

    Pie shop (347) 541-9874 Route

  18. 58. Pie Face

    1407 Broadway, New York, NY 10018

    Pie shop (855) 444-3388 Route

  19. 59. Pie Face

    464 9th Ave, New York, NY 10018

    Pie shop (212) 518-2654 Route

  20. 60. Pie Face

    1691 Broadway, New York, NY 10019

    Pie shop (855) 444-3388 Route

  21. 61. Pied Piper Pies

    307 Main St, Highland Falls, NY 10928

    Pie shop (845) 446-2030 Route

  22. 62. Tart Tart Bakery

    52 Jericho Turnpike Floor 1, Mineola, NY 11501

    French bakery (646) 671-1735 Route

  23. 63. The Pie Lady

    0 Hay Path, Colonie, NY 12189

    Pie shop (518) 813-7040 Route

  24. 64. The Village Tart

    63 Broad St, Schuylerville, NY 12871

    Pie shop (518) 507-6476 Route

  25. 65. Pie Lady & Son

    125 Main St Ste 7, Nyack, NY 10960

    Pie shop Route

  26. 66. Torte Jeff Pie Co.

    218 East Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY 11777

    Pie shop (631) 456-1532 Route

  27. 67. Pie Lady & Son

    125 Main St, Nyack, NY 10960

    Pie shop (845) 535-3290 Route

  28. 68. The Pie Shoppe

    7 West Village Green, Hicksville, NY 11801

    Pie shop (516) 719-4141 Route

  29. 69. Yongtai Bakery Inc

    4111 8th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232

    Pie shop (646) 421-5808 Route

  30. 70. Little Log Cabin Pie Shoppe

    32 Old Town Rd, Beacon, NY 12508

    Pie shop (845) 440-3427 Route

  31. 71. Sugar Plum Apple Pie

    600 Trinity Ave, New York, NY 10455

    Pie shop (347) 638-7949 Route

  32. 72. Perfect Pie

    3315 Greenpoint Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101

    Pie shop (888) 406-4936 Route

  33. 73. Pritchards Pie and Pastry Company

    10150 Sulphur Springs Rd, Lee Center, NY 13363

    Pie shop (315) 942-2462 Route

Keep exploring

All of New York5,461 bakeries statewideBakeries near meSorted by distance from you