Bakery café in Brookhaven, NY

Craving something from a bakery café? These 8 spots in Brookhaven are the ones we list as bakery cafés. Each one has its own page with hours, a pinned map and one-tap directions.

More in Brookhaven

All bakeries in Brookhaven 25

Closest to you

Share your location once and we will sort bakeries from closest to farthest, with the distance to each.

8 listed. Hover a bakery to find it on the map.

  1. 1. Bagel Lady Cafe

    99 Ny-25a #18, Brookhaven, NY 11786

    Bagel shop Hours listed (631) 744-0071 Route

  2. 2. Hilltop Bagel Cafe

    623 Horseblock Road, Brookhaven, NY 11738

    Bagel shop (631) 846-1828 Route

  3. 3. Bagelicious Cafe

    1031 Ny-112, Brookhaven, NY 11776

    Bagel shop (631) 642-0741 Route

  4. 4. Bagels Your Way Cafe

    2799 Ny-112 #8, Brookhaven, NY 11763

    Bagel shop (631) 758-6467 Route

  5. 5. Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe

    379 Ny-25a, Brookhaven, NY 11778

    Bagel shop (631) 744-7500 Route

  6. 6. Panera Bread

    367 Sunrise Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11772

    Artisan bread bakery (631) 687-1866 Route

  7. 7. Pete's Bagels and Brunch

    587 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11941

    Bagel shop (631) 325-8410 Route

  8. 8. Your Bagel Cafe

    508 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11934

    Bagel shop (631) 909-8900 Route

Keep exploring

Bakeries in Huntington23 bakeries nearby in Suffolk CountyBakeries in Islip22 bakeries nearby in Suffolk CountyBakeries in Riverhead20 bakeries nearby in Suffolk CountyBakeries in Babylon18 bakeries nearby in Suffolk CountyBakeries in Smithtown16 bakeries nearby in Suffolk CountyBakeries in West Babylon13 bakeries nearby in Suffolk CountyOpen right nowSee which bakeries near you are open at this momentAll of New York5,461 bakeries statewide