Bakeries in Oyster Bay, New York
Looking for fresh bread, pastries or a cake in Oyster Bay? Here are 19 bakeries across the city and the surrounding parts of Nassau County, sorted with the most-searched spots first.
With about 299,540 residents, that is roughly one bakery for every 15,765 people; the earliest weekday opener we track is East Norwich Bagels at 5:30 AM; Dortoni keeps the latest hours, until 8 PM; 2 of the 2 bakeries with published hours open on Sundays.
19bakeries listed
2with published hours
299,540residents (2024 est.)
local time in Oyster Bay
19 listed. Hover a bakery to find it on the map.
-
1. East Norwich Bagels
1011 Oyster Bay Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11732
-
8. Panera Bread
5274 Sunrise Highway, Oyster Bay, NY 11762
-
14. Brooklyn Delights
848 main street, Frank Ave #1, Oyster Bay, NY 11735
-
19. L'AMI Bakery and Cafe
H Mart, 336 N Broadway, Oyster Bay, NY 11753
Oyster Bay bakeries at a glance
| Bakeries listed | 19 |
|---|---|
| Residents per bakery | 15,765 |
| With published opening hours | 2 |
| Open on Sundays (of those with hours) | 2 |
| With a phone number | 19 |
| Earliest weekday opening | East Norwich Bagels, 5:30 AM |
| Latest closing time | Dortoni, 8 PM |
| County | Nassau County |
| Time zone | Eastern Time |
Bakery styles in Oyster Bay
Frequently asked questions
How many bakeries are in Oyster Bay, NY?
Our directory lists 19 bakeries in Oyster Bay, including cake shops, donut and bagel shops and bakery cafés.
Which bakery opens earliest in Oyster Bay?
East Norwich Bagels has the earliest listed weekday opening, at 5:30 AM.
Are bakeries in Oyster Bay open on Sunday?
2 of the 2 bakeries with published hours are open on Sundays. Use the Open now page to see who is open at this moment.
What kind of bakeries are common in Oyster Bay?
The most common specialty is bakery cafés (4 listings), followed by bagel shops and artisan bread & sourdough bakeries.
How do I find the bakery closest to me?
Use the "Near me" button: we ask your browser for your location once and sort bakeries from closest to farthest, with the distance shown for each one.